2023/10/08
If there are anything requiring 100% attention in circuit design, they must include isolators.
Isolators themselves do not have special computing, processing or conversion capabilities, but its evolution is inextricably linked to the development of industry, automotive, medical, and home electronics, etc. In view of the fact that their high reliability and performance soundly underpins system security, you should not brush aside isolators in your circuit design.
Some may see isolation a too-often-heard topic, but it actually plays an important role in protecting circuit and personal safety.
In simple terms, the voltage of the execution system and the control system in electronic devices varies greatly – hundreds VAC vs. low VDC. In life, we isolate low-voltage and high-voltage systems, which also applies to circuit design. High-voltage systems often are more prone to electrostatic discharge, radio frequency, switching pulse and power disturbance, which can cause a voltage surge that is a thousand times higher than the voltage limit of many electronic components. Most importantly, these voltage surges are more likely to cause harm to human body, in addition to the noise and damages to electronic circuit.
Here’s a simple example. The battery voltage in an electric vehicle (EV) can reach 400V, or even 800V, but the driver can calmly and safely operate all devices, instruments and knobs inside it. Behind this calmness and safety, various forms of isolation play a crucial role – they build a safe and reliable connection between high and low voltage systems.
Considering such a profound effect, the selection of isolation type particularly matters.
Since the day one of electricity use by human, people have longed for safe and reliable means of power control. In the 1830s, Joseph Henry, an American physicist, invented the electromagnetic relay using the theory of electromagnetic induction when he studied circuit control. Inspired by the phenomenon of magnetic force generation and disappearance in power-on and power-off conditions, he used a electromagnet to control the opening and closing of another circuit with high voltage and high current, enabling remote control and protection of the circuit.
By controlling the electromagnet using a dry cell, a 220V AC electric circuit can be driven to enable safe control (or information transmission), which has a ring of “moving a thousand pounds with four ounces”. This simple procedure is the underlying principle of isolation, i.e. two unrelated circuits that are insulated from each other are connected in certain way.
However, electromagnetic relay has obvious disadvantages, such as large footprint, high power consumption, and easy vulnerability.
To overcome the aforesaid shortcomings, optocoupler came into being. It uses photovoltaic conversion to enable transmission and control, and implements a similar function at IC level. Opto-isolator, based on photoresistor, was launched in 1968. Compared with transformers, optocoupler that featured small footprint, light weight, low cost and high reliability, quickly became the mainstream in the market. The era of optocoupler development also saw the evolution of integrated circuit (IC) and information technology. With increasing interaction between low-voltage control and computing units and high-power motors and power supplies, optocouplers have been greatly improved.
Undoubtedly, performance, power consumption and footprint are never-to-evade topics in the microelectronics world, and any strong technology cannot steer away from them. Optocouplers now meet the same challenges with electromagnetic relay – constrained by laser and photosensitive diode, optocouplers lose their edge in terms of footprint, power consumption, and reliability.
Thanks to the advances of semiconductor technology, digital isolators have become rising stars.
It’s not difficult to understand digital isolators. They are similar to optocouplers, except that the photovoltaic conversion and modulation is changed to other technologies. However, it’s noted that optical attenuation will not occur in digital isolators. Unlike optocouplers, digital isolators provide many benefits, including good switching characteristic, low vulnerability to aging, high reliability, high voltage withstand ability, high speed, and energy transferability. All these are underpinned by semiconductor technology.
By underlying principles, digital isolators can be divided into capacitive isolators and magnetic ones.
Capacitive isolator, as its name suggests, uses the micro-capacitors inside the IC for high voltage isolation on the left and right sides, and adopts highly dielectric materials in the middle for voltage isolation. Capacitor is a device that can store charge, and comprises two conductor plates and medium. It allows high frequency to pass through, but blocks low frequency. The intermediate medium can isolate low frequency or DC high voltage signals.
Using capacitor’s characteristic of allowing high frequency to pass through but blocking low frequency, modulation and transmission of signals can be performed. When a High-Low digital signal is input, the signal will be modulated inside the IC – the high frequency signal will be modulated into low frequency signal, allowing it to be transmitted to the other side of the IC. Typical OOK (On Off Key) modulation is as follows: “0, 1” signals will be modulated using different frequencies. For example, 1 represents high-frequency signal, and 0 represents unmodulated DC signal, and then two state switching signals are transmitted.
Block diagram of capacitive isolator product and schematic diagram of OOK modulation
Magnetic isolators are similar to capacitive ones, except that the former uses coils and electromagnetic conversion to implement data transmission.
In a nutshell, digital isolators further address the disadvantages of optocouplers in terms of reliability, transmission rate, robustness, footprint, and service life.
Perfection never exists in the realm of technology. Digital isolators boast visible advantages, but there are always trade-offs.
First, digital isolators are relatively new, so their reliability is continuously being improved and demonstrated. With the successive introduction of related international and domestic standards, a complete range of approval processes and standards have been established, and customers from various industries have gradually given their recognition.
Second, optocouplers still account for a dominant share in the industry, especially in some conventional applications. Therefore, the shift from optocoupler to digital isolator cannot be done overnight, because the pins and input type of digital isolators are not fully compatible. This requires changes of design. Sometimes customers are not willing to switch to digital isolator because of risk considerations. To this end, there is an Pin to Pin replacement alternative in the industry. In this solution, the optocoupler can be directly replaced and pins are compatible, and the built-in circuit is implemented in the input characteristics to simulate the diode characteristics. In this way, digital isolator can function exactly same with a optocoupler device in same application settings, and direct design replacement can be achieved.
At last, common mode interference may occur in capacitive isolators, which needs to be suppressed.
A typical OOK technology is simple and clear, i.e. the input signal is directly and correspondingly modulated and then demodulated on the other side. After high-frequency modulation, the signal and high-frequency common mode circuit are transmitted through one same path, so there will be common mode interference. This is also a shortcoming of ordinary capacitive isolators.
Considering the above-mentioned problems, particular attention should be paid to the selection of devices. There are several methods to significantly enhance the immunity to common-mode interference. Taking the Chinese isolator manufacturer NOVOSENSE as an example, it has developed the Adaptive OOK® proprietary modulation technology on the basis of OOK, which improves the capability of digital isolators to resist common-mode interference.
The so-called Adaptive OOK® technology uses the common mode detection circuit inside the IC to detect the state of common mode signals, and then depending on the signals detected, dynamically and adaptively modulates the internal key circuit characteristics or gains. When the common mode noise is large, it can better suppress the noise, so as to provide higher robustness and enhanced immunity to common mode interference.
Another benefit of adaptive modulation is that high common-mode interference resistance does not need to be guaranteed at full operation state. Only when the instantaneous interference is relatively high, the circuit needs to perform more functions to suppress interference. In most cases where there is no harsh conditions and a low requirement for common-mode interference resistance, Adaptive OOK® technology can strike a good balance between system properties and power consumption to optimize the overall performance.
In the digital isolator market segment, only a few companies provide magnetic isolators, and capacitive isolators are the preferred choice of more manufacturers. What’s more, the number of capacitive isolators sold is growing very fast. In addition to patent related reasons, the overall manufacturing process of capacitive isolators is relatively simple, and does not differ greatly from general non-isolated devices in terms of wafer production. This allows capacitive isolators to deliver a big cost advantage.
Furthermore, the process capability and performance of capacitive isolators are constantly improved. Particularly, their voltage withstand and surge resistance capabilities have been basically comparable to magnetic isolators, allowing capacitive isolators to meet the requirements of a wide range of applications.
The products from NOVOSENSE can prove the above-mentioned trend. For example, the first-generation NSI81xx series meets the basic isolation requirements. The second-generation NSI82xx series answers the requirements of enhanced isolation, and provides enhanced resistance to common-mode interference, EMC performance and other electrical properties. According to NOVOSENSE, its third-generation products will further improve the voltage withstand capability and robustness.
Figure: Different isolation ratings
When it comes to the design of a capacitive isolator, the theory is simple, but the optimization and innovation of some processes and microarchitectures will have highly great effects on the overall performance. A case in point, from OOK to Adaptive OOK®, NOVOSENSE has done a lot to realize this “one-step-further” effort.
Performance. Process capability and microarchitecture optimization contribute to continuous improvement of voltage withstand capability. For example, assuming that highly dielectric SiO2 is filled, different elements are also needed to further improve the voltage withstand capability. In addition, the electric field strength distribution of the capacitor can greatly affect the voltage withstand capability of isolator. Therefore, the design of capacitor structure, shape and other micro-architectures of each manufacturer, will affect the performance.
Robustness. Isolator products are more widely used in industry, automotive and other high-voltage applications. Isolators are required to meet safety specifications. In applications involving safety, the selection of isolators having safety approvals is mandatory.
To match specific requirements of analog, interfaces and signal chains, manufacturers need to introduce different product families for more applications. Isolator makes no exception. By combining the basic isolation function with other interfaces, drives or sampling knowledge, isolator technology can have wider applications.
Backward derivation of product definition from applications is the main idea of product development, and also the greatest challenge. The definition of “isolation+” product around applications is not exactly same with that of pure digital isolators.
Take isolated driver for example, in addition to the digital signal processing capability, manufacturers are required to be familiar with the power knowledge related to the driver in specific applications and ensure compatibility with power tubes from different manufacturers. Furthermore, SiC and other third generation wide band gap semiconductor applications pose more security and data transmission requirements for isolated drivers.
For isolated interface products, the ESD and anti-interference capabilities need to be considered. Isolated sampling also requires a good expertise in high-precision signal chain.
In addition, isolators sometimes need to be used together with power supply. In this setting, isolators that integrate the isolated power supply were launched.
According to our knowledge, NOVOSENSE and other Chinese and global manufacturers coincidentally plan more isolation product categories – shifting from single category to “isolation+” expansion strategy, so as to provide isolation capability for more products.
An increasing number of new applications and new markets push digital isolators to the same starting line with optocouplers. More and more niche applications, including EV, photovoltaics, and energy storage, are emerging, and the demand for digital isolators is rocketing. Customers are more willing to select digital isolators in the design of these new applications.
We have witnessed the glory of electromagnetic relays and optocouplers, and now the era of digital isolators comes. Check your circuit board carefully. If other parts already adopt the latest technology, but optical coupled isolator is still used, this is definitely not the best choice. Discover more about digital isolator technology. In the next article, we will focus on the key parameters of digital isolators, which will also help you to get a better picture of this technology.
